What each tool is built for
| Spine 2D | After Effects | |
|---|---|---|
| Made for | Game animation | Motion design and compositing |
| Output | Skeleton data, atlas and image sheet | Video, or a sequence of images |
| Played by | A runtime inside the game | The game shows pre-rendered frames |
| File weight | Light: one set of images reused | Heavy: one image per frame |
| Blending between animations | Yes, at play time | No, each sequence is fixed |
| Effects such as glow, blur, particles | Limited inside the tool | Very rich |
Where Spine wins
- Characters with many states. Idle, win, big win and bonus share the same drawings.
- Anything that must react. A symbol that responds the instant a win lands.
- Games that load in a browser. Weight matters, and a frame sequence gets heavy fast.
- Late changes. Timing is adjusted without re-rendering.
Where After Effects wins
- Trailers and promotional videos.
- Intro sequences played once, as a video.
- Effects that change shape completely: smoke, liquid, light, explosions, rendered as short sequences.
- Previsualisation. Mocking up how a win sequence should feel before building it in the game.
How they work together
Most game productions use both.
- The sequence is first sketched as a video mock-up, often in After Effects, to agree on the rhythm.
- Characters and symbols are rigged and animated in Spine.
- Complex effects are rendered as short image sequences and played on top.
- Coins, sparks and dust are generated by the game engine's particle system.
- The developer assembles everything and tunes the timing in the game.
What about exporting After Effects animations to the web?
Vector animations made in After Effects can be exported as lightweight data files through the Lottie format, which is widely used for interface animation in apps and websites. It suits icons and simple motion. It is not designed for a rigged game character with many blended states.
Which should you ask for?
| You need | Ask for |
|---|---|
| An animated mascot or animated symbols | Spine |
| A big win sequence | Spine for the character, sequences or particles for the effects |
| A trailer for the game | After Effects |
| A loading or intro animation shown once | Either; a video is simplest |
| Animated buttons in an app | Lottie, or code |
In slot games
A slot is a browser game where the same symbols appear thousands of times in several states. That is exactly the case skeletal animation handles well. See how slot machine animation is made and what Spine animation is.
Not sure which one your game needs?
Art, animation and code from one team. Custom slots from €4,000.
Get a quote